Working Document Series Open Access 2014 RUF-33904

The dissonance between concept and practice: The WATERCAP project as an example of a partial paradigm shift towards system innovation

N. FaltmannL. HallerProbst. LorenzM. Wurzinger

Download Read online

Abstract

153 words

Approaches related to system innovation, including participatory action and monitoring have become mainstream in planning and implementing development projects. It is far from clear, however, what different stakeholders mean when they commit to these approaches. This study investigated a specific project “Strengthening Universities Capacities for Mitigating Climate Change Induced Water Vulnerabilities in East Africa – WATERCAP” to understand how stakeholders conceptualized these approaches and put them into practice. The project intended to strengthen the capacities of universities in East Africa to mitigate climate change induced water vulnerability. We used indicators derived from concepts of innovation systems and Reflexive Monitoring and Action to analyze data gathered by applying qualitative methods. Our results show a dissonance between espoused theory and practice, as structural realities and personal interests dominated the project processes. The study raises the question whether communicative action for system innovation can be achieved in results-oriented development projects which require accountability to external donors.

Subjects

1 category